Thursday, February 24, 2011

Free Entrance

We live in a world in which there is almost a free passage of goods, services and capital. Nowadays anyone can transfer money from one country to another by simply pushing a button. The simplicity by which products are taken from one place to another is enormous. Any firm can move its production to another country almost without difficulty. Multinationals have been moving its production to different places in order to reduce costs. Textile firms in Israel have moved their production plants to Jordan, for example, and big firms have created sweatshops en Third World countries employing men, women and children in subhuman conditions without discriminating anyone in the exploitation process. While products and capital move almost without restrictions, the limitations to the free passage of people continue to be strong and are becoming stronger.
These restrictions have not impeded or reduced immigration. In a globalized world, where anything can be moved from one place to another, to continue the enormous restrictions to immigration is problematic. There are no moral qualms for US firms to establish maquiladores in Mexico exploiting both Mexican and US workers; being this, part of the new economic order. However, restricting entrance of Mexicans to the US is allowed and for many the restrictions must be stronger.
This almost absurd situation has its foremost expression in illegal immigration. Thousands of persons enter other countries illegally searching for a better life and in most cases they are exploited by local forces. They work for immoral salaries without any social or legal protection. This reduces the negotiating capacity of the local workers by having a working force willing to work for less than minimum wage and without social protection. Meanwhile, the government uses foreign workers as an excuse to justify unemployment, arguing that these immigrants are taking the jobs of local workers.
In several places, local workers and popular sectors, instead of getting together with illegal immigrants and fight for honorable salaries and social protection for all, they accept the government's arguments and give place to expressions of nationalism and racism. The practice of blaming illegal immigrants for unemployment and expel them, while at the same time allowing new immigrants enter through the back door in order to maintain the system, reduces solidarity between workers; solidarity which has been lost in many societies.
What should be done? In the same way there is almost free movement of capital and goods, the same must be allowed for people. The only restrictions should be when the immigrant is a risk for public security, i.e. a terrorist or criminal.
More than one of you will ask why a country which has achieved economic development must allow people from poor countries to enjoy these economic benefits. On the one hand we do not have any problem with local firms moving their production plants to other places and exploiting workers there. We have no problem with consuming products from sweatshops, abusing other's natural resources, and other exploitation mechanisms, as long as the foreigner does not enter my land. Do you wish to reduce labor immigration? Let us work for the development of poor countries, eliminate exploitation and abuses and I assure you that labor immigration will be reduced. Most immigrants will remain or will return to their places or origin if they would be able to enjoy an honorable life for them and their families there. For all nationalists and racists who demonstrated in Israel against African immigrants, know that many of them are returning to their homes after the victory in South Sudan plebiscite (Back to Africa).
It is not my position to stop immigrants from coming or making them return to their countries. I believe that the cultural and economic contribution of immigration is much more beneficial than detrimental. As one person commented (I'll keep him anonymous) in a recent conference on Latin America: "…after decades of Latin immigration to Spain, Spaniards have become friendlier…" I will add that they play better football. What would European national teams and European football do without immigration?  

No comments:

Post a Comment