In the last days with the escalating of the protest in Egypt and the fragile future for the Mubarak regime, voices have been heard in Israel on how military intelligence failed (once more) in predicting the Egyptian uproar.
Israeli newspaper Haaretz indicates that the new IDF intelligence chief failed to predict Egypt uprising (article). "On Tuesday, the day the unrest began that led to the collapse of the Egyptian cabinet, Israel's new head of Military Intelligence told a Knesset committee that President Hosni Mubarak's government was not under threat," the article says. What can I say rather than great start Major General!
You should have heard former South Commander, (re) General Doron Almog in an interview this morning on Israeli radio B. When asked what he thought would be Egypt's future he answered something like this (citation is not exact): "I see three options: one, is that Mubarak regains control; second, Suleiman gains control while slowly Mubarak steps down; three, the worst scenario, the Muslim Brotherhood gains power." So the journalist asked him what about the coming to power of non Islamic opposition, "well, that is also a possibility; and always there the chance that a liberal democracy comes or an unexpected change can also occur." Well done (re) General Almog you got all bases covered!!!
This reminds me of my father and his prediction on the Paraguayan dictator Stroessner's regime. We were on the beach in Uruguay's famous resort, Punta Del Este, when a group of Paraguayans pro Stroessner were talking about politics. My father, born in Paraguay and anti Stroessner, wanted to avoid an argument so he said confidently: "Stroessner has been in power for thirty five years and he will remain for thirty five years more." When leaving the beach he whispered: "I hope he is thrown tomorrow and he burns in hell." Well, I cannot know if he is burning in hell, but he was overthrown the other day.
Let's be fair, we cannot ask Maj. General Kochavi (new IDF intelligence chief) to be a prophet. And the issue here is not about Kochavi's knowledge or lack of it. I personally never heard about him before and probably he has a wide knowledge. The problem here is something else.
Since its founding Israel has been dependent on intelligence's capacity in predicting enemies' conduct and acting upon it. There is no doubt that the record is on the side of the intelligence community, they are one of the reasons Israel still exists, despite the fiasco of 1973. The problem or my problem is the constant reliance on military perspective in analyzing situations; an understandable flaw in Israel.
I must confess that my knowledge on Egypt is practically none. A part from reading a couple of Bernard Lewis books (which I fondly recommend) and an undergraduate course on "the State in the Middle East" I know nothing about Egypt. However, stating that a regime is under no threat, when its people are suffering from huge socio economic problems and have been under a dictatorship for almost sixty years and thirty under Mubarak is at best risky if not irresponsible.
Call me an optimist but I tend (or want) to believe that all authoritarian regimes are under threat, they must be under threat, but I can understand that a military official sees authoritarian regimes as stable. Of course I am biased, I am Latino American, and as such I have no doubt that military intelligence is an oxymoron. If you had seen television programs on Saturday in both Israeli channels the "experts" in Egypt offered an exclusively military perspective. Also in radio programs the majority of experts brought their military expertise. However, as an academic woman, whose name I couldn’t get because I tune in late, said: "the problem with the military perspective is that they forget the people and general society and focus too much on the top of the pyramid." I believe is time we stop relying exclusively on military perspectives presenting them as objectives when they are not.
Now turning to Egypt, first of all I do not have the slightest idea what will happen there; but if I had to bet I'll go with (re) General Almog's opinion. My desire is that change comes and that it will be for good. I hope Egyptians are able to impose their desires and establish a democratic SECULAR regime. Not because the Muslim Brotherhood is bad for Israel, I believe that all religious based regime or religious parties are bad for the people no matter which religion. So, to the Egyptian people I say well done, good luck and be wise enough not to fall on a worst dictatorship. Seeing the spontaneous demonstrations of the youth in Egypt fills me with pride and hope.
The West must understand that international politics cannot be exclusively based on neo realism and national interest. Values do matter; continuing supporting authoritarian regimes has its costs and one of it is the possibility is having an Islamist fundamentalist regime in Egypt. By this I do not mean that democracy must be imposed as neo conservatives argue, rather democracy has to be a down up process in order to succeed.
To my readers, well let's give strength to the Egyptian people and try to predict what will be the future of that country; any ideas?
No comments:
Post a Comment